Latin American Election Watch: 2006

Not only is this a crucial election year in the United States, Canada, Israel, and many other countries, but it is also a whirlwind election year in Latin America.

The first of these Latin American elections began this winter, with Honduras on November 27. Then came parliamentary elections in Venezuela, presidential in Bolivia, and just yesterday, Chile.

You may be asking, "Who cares? Why do elections in Latin America matter to the U.S.?"

Read! Below the fold...

If we had not gone into Iraq in 2003, Latin America would probably be our biggest international concern right now. Not only is this huge and fast-growing continent right below us, but we are deeply connected both economically and politically with these countries. If we weren't, would Reagan have ever interfered in Nicaragua? Would we give a #$^% about Hugo Chavez or Fidel Castro?

These elections are an important international event, and even more important for United States interests. So, with that, here's a roundup:

Honduras - November 27, 2005

The National Party, considered right of center, lost to the opposition Liberals. The new leader will be Mel Zelaya, a Liberal, but one who eked into office with less than 50% of the vote. The narrow Liberal win should mean cautious and divided politics over the next few years in this country.

Venezuela parliamentary elections - December 4, 2005

The extreme-left Hugo Chavez, president of Venezuela, had a huge victory for his party when they won nearly every seat in the legislature. This was partly due to election boycotting by other parties, but partly due to Chavez's popularity. The tightened Chavez grip on the legislature could mean even more tense conditions between Venezuela and the U.S.

Bolivia - December 18, 2005

Chavez ally and far-left coca activist Evo Morales won a convincing plurality to become Bolivia's first Amerindian president. While Bolivians hope for lessened poverty and more labor-friendly policies with Morales, the hard-left victory will mean a more antagonistic relationship with the U.S., just as with Chavez in Venezuela.

Chile - December 11 first-round; January 15, 2006 runoff

Yesterday's runoff provided a 53-47 victory for Michelle Bachelet, soon-to-be the first female president of Chile, and leader of the center-left coalition that has led Chile since the end of Pinochet in 1990. Chile is one of the few moderate success stories in South America, and satisfaction with the current state of affairs is probably what provided Bachelet's victory. While Bachelet is a Socialist, the government should be more "traditionally liberal" and less extreme than its counterparts in Venezuela or Bolivia.

And next, the upcoming ones.

Costa Rica - February 5, 2006

Former president Oscar Arias, of the National Liberation Party, is considered the frontrunner. While president in 1987, Arias won the Nobel Peace Prize. His party is considered a socialist one, so I'm assuming leadership under Arias would put Costa Rica in a left-leaning political mold, but I don't know enough about Costa Rica politics.

Haiti - February 7, 2006

Elections here should be turbulent and dangerous. My personal bet would be on a leftist winning in this poverty-torn country, but all bets are off when the foundation of a country is so precarious.

Colombia legislative elections - March 12, 2006

Legislative elections here should cancel out Venezuela, as President Alvaro Uribe, a solid conservative, is quite popular. Colombia is traditionally a much more right-leaning country than some of its neighbors, possibly because of the "war on drugs" that is so prevalent here. Anyhow, Uribe's grip should tighten.

El Salvador parliamentary elections - March 12, 2006

On the same day as Colombia, El Salvador will be having its parliamentary elections. I don't know much about the outlook, but I do know that like Colombia, El Salvador is a more conservative country run by the right-wing. Whether that helps the incumbents or not, I don't know.

Peru - April 9, 2006

The election here is closely divided. Lourdes Flores, of the right-of-center National Unity, may be the frontrunner, but is only barely ahead of leftist Ollanta Humala and/or former president Alberto Fujimori. WIDE OPEN.

Dominican Republic parliamentary elections - May 16, 2006

Who knows.

Colombia - May 28, 2006

Uribe should be reelected. I think.

Mexico - July 2, 2006

This could be the most important Latin American election of 2006 for the U.S. A tight three-way race is developing between the conservative PAN's Felipe Calderon, the left-leaning PRI's Roberto Madrazo, and the leftist PRD's Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador. Lopez Obrador, the former Mayor of Mexico City, may be the frontrunner, but only by a little. After six years of Bush-friendly rule in Mexico, it will be very interesting to see what happens here.

Brazil - October 1, 2006

Like Mexico, extremely important to watch. The incumbent is left-winger Luis Inacio Lula da Silva, who seemed a shoo-in until widespread corruption in the party ranks took the headlines. Sao Paulo Mayor Jose Serra is Lula's toughest opponent, and the race is neck-in-neck. If Serra wins, analysts may consider it a sign of increasing centrism in Latin American politics.

Ecuador - October 15, 2006

Wide open. I can't find any info.

Nicaragua - November 27, 2006

This will be very interesting. Former president Daniel Ortega (yes, that one) is one of the leading candidates, again running for the Sandinista Party. Results are not certain, but the mere fact that Ortega could win suggests there is dissatisfaction with the conservative government.

and finally...

Venezuela - December 2006

Yawn. Chavez will be back, and probably with 80% of the vote too!


Display:


The legacy of the US is everywhere (3.00 / 1)

Interesting isn't it that the two countries (Colombia, El Salvador) who remain rather steadfast in their right-of-center politics are the two in which the US has done the most wholesale meddling recently?

Also, who would have ever thought that the PRI would be considered left-of-center in a good way? But with the Zapatistas touring the nation on their goodwill mission, who the hell knows what's happening in Mexico anymore.

Also, while things of course can change, Peru has banned Fujimora from running again.  What I'd love to see (though again, who knows) is Chile to extradite Fujimora to stand trial as part of a natural gas agreement that brings Chile, Bolivia and Peru together and manages to start healing old wounds. Report this morning about how Argentina has cut off natural gas to Chile which is about 25% of their power. With Morales and Bachalet coming in and some combo of Chavez, Lula and Kirchner as behind the scenes power brokers, who knows. Solidarity seems to be pretty big lately.

Speaking of, I really don't see how Lula hangs on. Not only is the corruption thing a really big deal, but he hasn't delivered. In the minds of his supporters especially, he sold out and abandoned his principles. He, of course, says he's faced the realities of governing, but that isn't gonna put bread on the table.

The thing is, Latin America keeps swinging left to right and back again because nobody ever manages to bring people out of poverty really.  And the reason is the US doesn't allow for it. To be on top, someone has to be beneath you. The difference now is that someone with some economic clout (Chavez) is starting to swing it around a bit.

by Lucas O'Connor on Mon Jan 16, 2006 at 01:06:16 PM EST

Some thoughts (none / 0)

First, I doubt that the far left turn taking place in Latin America would be happening if the US was able to maintain good and productive relationships with the people there.  

I have thought a lot about Latin America's turn to communism in the 60's - 80's.  I never quite understood what the Soviet system had to offer in practical terms.  I have spent a lot of time in that part of the world, and asked about this whenever I could.  The general sense is that the turn was not to communism, but away from the US due to US neo-colonalism and illegal interventions.  That is, many people felt that to defend against American hegomeny, they needed to allign with the communist block.  

Now that Bush has furthur clamped down on Cuba, sponsored a coup against a democratically-elected leader in Venezuela, and has put diplomatic pressure on other countries to keep in lock step with US interests, the same phenomenon is taking place.  Why would Guatamala or Costa Rica join the 'colalition of the willing' in Iraq?  Because they believed US lies about terror and WMD, or because Bushco put diplomatic and economic pressure on their governments?  

So far, I am pretty happy with the leftist governments being elected.  I dont think we need to assume that this is a bad thing, or that these governments would be antagonistic with the US (with the exception of Chavez and Castro for obvious reasons, they were both threatened with coups or invasions sponsored by the US government.  Same goes for Ortega, of course, if he is elected.)

Finally, Fujimori in Peru may nuture delusions about return to power, as pathetic as Imelda Marcos' attempts to run for president of the Phillipines.  But last I heard, he was arrested in Chile and is being extradited to Peru to face charges of various crimes and corruptions, including the embezzlement of about 600 million US dollars.  Which makes him one of the most successful kleptocrats in the history of the world.  

John McCain loves war.
by Winston Smith on Mon Jan 16, 2006 at 08:24:33 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.